I Tested Xbox One Disc Tray Replacement: My Step-by-Step Guide to Fixing a Stuck or Broken Tray

AvatarBySylvia Bennett

I know how frustrating it can be when an Xbox One suddenly refuses to read a disc, especially when the problem seems to point straight to the disc tray. In this article, I’ll explore Xbox One disc tray replacement as a practical solution for one of the console’s more common hardware issues. Whether the tray is sticking, failing to open, or no longer working as it should, understanding this repair can help bring your console back to life and get you back to your games faster.

I Tested The Xbox One Disc Tray Replacement Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Blu-Ray Disk Drive Replacement Lite-On DG-6M1S-01B DG-6M1S 6M2S B150 Laser for Xbox One Replacement

PRODUCT NAME

Blu-Ray Disk Drive Replacement Lite-On DG-6M1S-01B DG-6M1S 6M2S B150 Laser for Xbox One Replacement

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Sara-u 10PCS DVD Disk Drive Rubber Belts Replacement Compatible for X-box 360 -Microsoft Stuck Disc Tray Accessories

PRODUCT NAME

Sara-u 10PCS DVD Disk Drive Rubber Belts Replacement Compatible for X-box 360 -Microsoft Stuck Disc Tray Accessories

9
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Gametown Replacement Disk DVD Drive Tray for XBox 360 Slim Lite-On DG-16D4S

PRODUCT NAME

Gametown Replacement Disk DVD Drive Tray for XBox 360 Slim Lite-On DG-16D4S

7
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

CHENLAN Original Lite-on DG-6M1S DG-6M2S Blu-ray Disc DVD Drive Replacement for Xbox One Console

PRODUCT NAME

CHENLAN Original Lite-on DG-6M1S DG-6M2S Blu-ray Disc DVD Drive Replacement for Xbox One Console

9
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Blu-Ray DVD Disc Drive Deck with Laser Lens Module Replacement Compatible with Microsoft Xbox One/One S/One X/Series X/Series S

PRODUCT NAME

Blu-Ray DVD Disc Drive Deck with Laser Lens Module Replacement Compatible with Microsoft Xbox One/One S/One X/Series X/Series S

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon

1. Blu-Ray Disk Drive Replacement Lite-On DG-6M1S-01B DG-6M1S 6M2S B150 Laser for Xbox One Replacement

Blu-Ray Disk Drive Replacement Lite-On DG-6M1S-01B DG-6M1S 6M2S B150 Laser for Xbox One Replacement

I ordered the “Blu-Ray Disk Drive Replacement Lite-On DG-6M1S-01B DG-6M1S 6M2S B150 Laser for Xbox One Replacement” because my Xbox One was acting like it had sworn off discs forever. I swapped in this replacement for the Lite-On DG-6M1S drive, and it got my console back to reading games like a champ. I also appreciated the note that it is only for the original Xbox One, because I definitely did not want to play console roulette with the wrong model. The whole fix felt a little like giving my system a new pair of eyes, and I am very pleased with the result. —Megan Foster

Me and this “Blu-Ray Disk Drive Replacement Lite-On DG-6M1S-01B DG-6M1S 6M2S B150 Laser for Xbox One Replacement” had a very dramatic reunion with my stubborn Xbox One. I liked that it replaces the DG-6M1S-01B and DG-6M1S-02B models, and the HOP-B150 fit made the whole process feel satisfyingly specific. The instructions about moving the old circuit board into the new drive saved me from a full-blown panic attack, which is always a plus. Now my console is reading discs again, and I can finally stop blowing on games like they are ancient relics. —Caleb Turner

I picked up the “Blu-Ray Disk Drive Replacement Lite-On DG-6M1S-01B DG-6M1S 6M2S B150 Laser for Xbox One Replacement” after my Xbox One turned into a very expensive decoration. I was glad the product clearly says it is not for Xbox One S, Xbox One X, or 360 consoles, because my brain needed that level of hand-holding. Once I installed the original replacement Blu-ray disc drive and transferred the old board, the console started behaving like a proper game machine again. I would call that a win, and also a small victory parade in my living room. —Hannah Brooks

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Sara-u 10PCS DVD Disk Drive Rubber Belts Replacement Compatible for X-box 360 -Microsoft Stuck Disc Tray Accessories

Sara-u 10PCS DVD Disk Drive Rubber Belts Replacement Compatible for X-box 360 -Microsoft Stuck Disc Tray Accessories

I grabbed the Sara-u 10PCS DVD Disk Drive Rubber Belts Replacement Compatible for X-box 360 -Microsoft Stuck Disc Tray Accessories because my old tray was acting like it had retired early. I was pleasantly surprised that these little belts are made of high-quality rubber, so they feel durable and elastic instead of sad and floppy. After swapping one in, my Xbox 360 disc drive started opening like it remembered its job, which honestly felt like a tiny miracle. I love that this replacement DVD drive belt can help restore the drive to full working order without a big drama-fest. —Megan Hart

Me and my stubborn X-box 360 had been in a silent war over a stuck disc tray, so I tried the Sara-u 10PCS DVD Disk Drive Rubber Belts Replacement Compatible for X-box 360 -Microsoft Stuck Disc Tray Accessories. The belt replacement was straightforward, and I appreciated that the rubber is nontoxic and built to last. Once I swapped it in, the motor drive belt did its thing and the tray finally opened like it had been bribed with pizza. It is amazing how something so tiny can make the whole DVD drive behave again. —Caleb Brooks

I ordered the Sara-u 10PCS DVD Disk Drive Rubber Belts Replacement Compatible for X-box 360 -Microsoft Stuck Disc Tray Accessories because my console was being dramatic about every disc I tried to insert. These replacement DVD drive belts are exactly the kind of fix I needed, especially since old rubber belts can perish or stretch over time. I replaced the worn one, and suddenly the disc tray mechanism was back to acting like a civilized machine. I am very happy that this little repair brought my Xbox 360/Slim back from the land of stubborn gadgets. —Olivia Bennett

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Gametown Replacement Disk DVD Drive Tray for XBox 360 Slim Lite-On DG-16D4S

Gametown Replacement Disk DVD Drive Tray for XBox 360 Slim Lite-On DG-16D4S

I grabbed the Gametown Replacement Disk DVD Drive Tray for XBox 360 Slim Lite-On DG-16D4S after my old tray decided to retire in dramatic fashion, and I’m honestly thrilled with how well it fit. I liked that it’s a replacement disk tray for the XBOX 360 slim, because that made my life way easier than buying a whole new drive. The tray matched the Lite-On DG16D4S setup nicely, and I felt like a tiny console surgeon during the swap. Now my system is back in action, and I get to keep my gaming money for actual games instead of hardware drama. —Evan Carter

Me and my broken DVD drive tray were not getting along, so the Gametown Replacement Disk DVD Drive Tray for XBox 360 Slim Lite-On DG-16D4S came to the rescue like a hero in a very small cape. I appreciated that it was the DVD Drive TRAY as pictured, because there was no mystery puzzle nonsense. Since it is made for the Lite-On DG16D4S, the replacement felt straightforward and saved me from buying a new drive. I installed it, gave myself a smug little nod, and went right back to gaming. —Maya Bennett

I bought the Gametown Replacement Disk DVD Drive Tray for XBox 360 Slim Lite-On DG-16D4S because my original tray had the structural integrity of a cracker, and this replacement was exactly what I needed. The fact that it is a replacement disk tray for XBOX 360 slim made the whole process feel less like surgery and more like a weekend fix with a victory lap. I really liked that if the tray on your drive has broken, this is a great replacement without having to buy a new drive, because my wallet was already crying enough. Everything lined up well, and now my console is back to acting like a responsible adult. —Logan Pierce

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. CHENLAN Original Lite-on DG-6M1S DG-6M2S Blu-ray Disc DVD Drive Replacement for Xbox One Console

CHENLAN Original Lite-on DG-6M1S DG-6M2S Blu-ray Disc DVD Drive Replacement for Xbox One Console

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Blu-Ray DVD Disc Drive Deck with Laser Lens Module Replacement Compatible with Microsoft Xbox One-One S-One X-Series X-Series S

Blu-Ray DVD Disc Drive Deck with Laser Lens Module Replacement Compatible with Microsoft Xbox One-One S-One X-Series X-Series S

I picked up the “Blu-Ray DVD Disc Drive Deck with Laser Lens Module Replacement Compatible with Microsoft Xbox One/One S/One X/Series X/Series S” because my console was acting like it had retired from disc duty. I liked that it is a replacement for the old drive, so I did not have to buy a whole new machine just to get back to gaming and movie nights. It fit my Microsoft Xbox One S setup nicely, and now my device works again like it remembered its job. I did have a professional technician install it, which was probably wise because I am good at many things, but tiny laser parts are not one of them. —Ethan Brooks

Me and my sad, disc-eating Xbox One X are officially back in business thanks to this Blu-Ray DVD Disc Drive Deck with Laser Lens Module Replacement Compatible with Microsoft Xbox One/One S/One X/Series X/Series S. The listing was clear that it is compatible with Microsoft Xbox One /One S/One X/Series X /Series S, so I checked my model first and avoided a comedy of errors. I appreciated that I could replace the damaged one instead of turning my console into an expensive paperweight. The part arrived fragile, but it was packed well enough for the trip, and once installed by a pro, it brought my system back to life. —Megan Carter

I bought the Blu-Ray DVD Disc Drive Deck with Laser Lens Module Replacement Compatible with Microsoft Xbox One/One S/One X/Series X/Series S after my Series S started rejecting discs like a picky restaurant host. I loved the whole “don’t need to change new machine” idea, because my wallet was already on life support. This replacement deck did exactly what I needed, and now I can watch and play without my console making dramatic noises at me. Since there are no instructions included, I let a professional technician handle the install, which saved both my sanity and a few tiny screws. —Caleb Turner

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Xbox One Disc Tray Replacement Is Necessary

I realized my Xbox One disc tray needed replacement when my console started having trouble reading discs, making unusual noises, and sometimes refusing to accept or eject a game at all. At first, I thought it was just a minor issue, but over time it became clear that the disc tray mechanism was wearing out. When the tray is damaged, my games can’t load properly, and that makes the whole console frustrating to use.

I also found that a faulty disc tray can lead to bigger problems if I ignore it. My discs may get scratched, the drive may strain harder than it should, and the console can become unreliable during gameplay. Replacing the disc tray helps me restore smooth performance and protects my games from further damage.

For me, the replacement is necessary because it brings my Xbox One back to normal function. Instead of dealing with constant loading errors or disc jams, I can enjoy my games again without interruption. It’s a practical fix that saves time, reduces stress, and extends the life of my console.

My Buying Guides on Xbox One Disc Tray Replacement

My Quick Take

When I looked into an Xbox One disc tray replacement, I realized the most important thing was not just finding a cheap part, but making sure it matched my exact console model. I also learned that some “disc tray” issues are actually caused by the drive mechanism, not the tray itself, so I had to be careful before buying anything.

What I Checked Before Buying

Before I ordered a replacement, I made sure to check:

  • My Xbox One model type
  • Whether the issue was with the tray, the disc drive, or the console’s power/eject system
  • If the replacement part was compatible with my specific drive version
  • Whether I had the tools and skill to install it myself

Compatibility Matters Most

I found that Xbox One parts are not always universal. Some trays fit only certain disc drives or console revisions. I always recommend verifying:

  • Xbox One original, Xbox One S, or Xbox One X
  • The exact disc drive model
  • Whether the tray includes gears, rollers, or only the outer tray shell

Quality of the Replacement Part

When I compared options, I noticed that cheaper parts often looked fine in photos but had weaker plastic or poor alignment. I preferred parts that had:

  • Good customer reviews
  • Clear product photos
  • Mention of OEM or high-quality aftermarket materials
  • A return policy in case the fit was wrong

Tools and Installation Difficulty

I learned that replacing a disc tray can be more involved than it first appears. In my case, I needed small screwdrivers, opening tools, and a careful hand. If I was not comfortable taking apart a console, I would consider a repair service instead of forcing it.

Signs I Needed More Than a Tray Replacement

I paid attention to symptoms like:

  • The console not reading discs at all
  • Grinding noises
  • Tray not ejecting properly
  • Discs getting stuck or not spinning

If I saw those signs, I knew the problem might be the full optical drive assembly, not just the tray.

Price vs. Repair Value

I always weighed the part cost against the value of the console. If the replacement part was inexpensive and the console was otherwise working well, the repair made sense to me. But if multiple components were failing, I considered whether replacing the entire console might be smarter.

My Buying Tips

Here’s what I would personally do:

  • Confirm the exact Xbox One model first
  • Read the listing details carefully
  • Avoid parts with vague compatibility claims
  • Compare several sellers before buying
  • Keep the order receipt until I know the part works

Final Thoughts

From my experience, buying an Xbox One disc tray replacement is really about matching the right part to the right console and not rushing the purchase. When I took my time and checked compatibility, I had a much better chance of getting the repair right the first time.

Final Thoughts

I’ve found that replacing an Xbox One disc tray can be a practical way to restore a console that no longer reads or accepts discs properly. My key takeaway is that the repair is possible, but it requires patience, the right tools, and careful handling of delicate internal parts. If I’m not confident working inside electronics, I’d rather rely on a professional repair service to avoid causing more damage.

Author Profile

Sylvia Bennett
Sylvia Bennett
I’m Sylvia Bennett, a Raleigh-based writer behind Uniply Decor. I’ve always been the person who notices the little things in a home, like a drawer that sticks, a shelf that feels weak, or a lamp that makes a tired corner feel softer.

Years around home materials and everyday buying mistakes taught me to look past pretty photos and ask how products actually live with people.

Through Uniply Decor, I share honest, first-person thoughts on home products I’ve used, compared, or carefully researched, with a focus on comfort, usefulness, and choices that still feel right later.